Dow Corning Created Its Own Worst Enemy — And Revenue Doubled to $6B

TL;DR - 1995 bankruptcy: Dow Corning filed Chapter 11 amid $32B breast implant lawsuits, emerging in 2004 after 9 years. ✓ (Wikipedia) - 2002 pivot: CFO Don Sheets launches Xiameter — online-only, no-service silicone sales at 10-15% discount, targeting bulk buyers. Leveraged $100M SAP infra for $0 new capex. ✓ (Computerworld) - Results: 3-month ROI, <10% cannibalization, 30%+ online sales by 2011, Xiameter ~40% of revenue. Company revenue from $2.5B (1995) to $6B peak (2010). ✓ (ICMR, Rubber News) - Lesson: Self-disruption via dual brands beats external commoditizers — if segmented right. ⚡

Hook + Background Picture this: Your company is crawling out of a 9-year bankruptcy hellhole, scarred by lawsuits over breast implants that ballooned to $32B in settlements. Silicone prices are tanking from Asian copycats commoditizing your bread-and-butter products. Sales reps are begging to slash prices. What do you do?

CFO Don Sheets didn't flinch. He proposed the unthinkable: Launch Xiameter, a brutal, no-frills online rival to cannibalize Dow Corning's own premium brand. No hand-holding, no tech support — just cheap bulk silicones for "economic buyers" who want product, not partnership.

Dow Corning, born 1943 as Dow Chemical-Corning JV, dominated silicones (7,000+ products). But 1980s implant crisis hit: ✓ 1995 Chapter 11 filing after $4.25B settlement push. (LA Times) Emerged 2004. Then commoditization: Standard silicones became price wars. High-service model bled margins. ⚡ Enter dual-brand pivot.

Core Decision Breakdown ### Decision 1: Bankruptcy — Fight or Fold? (1995) Dilemma: $32B Dow-paid settlements unaffordable; litigation endless. - Options: Continue suits (science vindication), liquidate, Chapter 11 restructure. ✓ Filed Chapter 11 May 1995; $32B phased over years. (Justia) ⚡ Bought time to innovate amid crisis — Xiameter gestated here. 💬 Bankruptcy as "strategic pause"? Counterintuitive lifeline for pivots.

Decision 2: Commoditization Response — Price War or Self-Cannibalize? (2001) Dilemma: Asian rivals dump standard silicones 20% cheaper; drop service or lose volume? - Options: Main-brand discounts, ignore low-end, new low-cost brand. ✓ Sheets picks Xiameter: 350+ commodities online, 10-15% off, $50k+/yr min, 51 countries launch Mar 2002. (Computerworld) ⚡ Targets "economic buyers" (price-first) vs Dow's "technical buyers" (service-needy). <10% crossover. (ICMR excerpts) 💬 Bravest B2B move: Fight your shadow to starve competitors.

Decision 3: Brand Independence — Sub-line or Standalone? (2001 Design) Dilemma: "Dow Basic" risks internal sabotage; too separate starves resources. ✓ Fully independent: New name (zero Google hits), culture, hiring (speed-test recruits). (Chief Executive) ⚡ Avoids "brand dilution" trap; sales teams can't shunt to high-margin. 💬 Blank-slate brand = zero baggage, full commitment.

Decision 4: Tech Stack — Greenfield or Leverage Existing? (2002 Build) Dilemma: True automation needs full SAP integration; risky during bankruptcy. ✓ $0 new capex: Haht frontend on $100M SAP backend. 4 months to live. Guaranteed ship dates. (Computerworld) ⚡ Zero-touch orders scale low-price model; unlocked underused capacity. 💬 Legacy tech as superpower — if ruthless in integration.

Decision 5: Scale & Integrate — Keep Separate or Absorb? (Post-2010) Dilemma: Xiameter hits 40% sales; Dow buyout (2016) pressures unity. ✓ Gradual fold into Dow Silicones (2018); Xiameter ethos persists in e-com. (Wikipedia) ⚡ Success proves model; absorption risks dilution but boosts scale. 💬 Innovation's fate: Fuel parent or fade?

FORKED Scorecard: Dual-Brand Disruption Rate your self-disruption readiness (1-10 per dimension):

Counterintuitive Discovery Premium brands thrive when you build their assassin — but 90% of dual-brand attempts fail. Why? Three killers: (1) Fuzzy segmentation — GM's Saturn vs Chevy bled into each other with no clear buyer split. (2) Internal sabotage — sales teams shunt deals to the profitable brand, starving the fighter. (3) Price anchor collapse — the cheap brand resets expectations for the whole portfolio (see: any airline's "basic economy" race to the bottom). ⚡

Dow Corning dodged all three. Economic vs Technical buyers were genuinely different people with different buying behavior — not the same customer shopping for a discount. Xiameter had its own team, its own culture, its own hiring bar. And the 10-15% gap was calibrated tight enough to avoid anchor collapse. Result: <10% cannibalization, 30%+ new customers. The assassin fed the empire instead of killing it.

Hidden Costs - Internal Wars: Sales reps hated "cannibal"; required firewall. (Chief Executive) - Brand Mortality: 2018 integration diluted Xiameter identity; success = eventual erasure. - Scale Trap: 30%+ online by 2011 locked in e-com dependency. (Rubber News) - Risk Backfire: Forrester warned 20% gap might force main-brand cuts. Didn't happen — but close. 💬 Glory short-lived?

What Would You Do? [Poll embeds here]

Test your gut above. Fork the status quo.

FAQ 1. Why did Dow Corning go bankrupt? Breast implant lawsuits; $32B Dow share phased via Chapter 11. ✓ (Wikipedia) 2. What is Xiameter exactly? No-frills e-com for standard silicones: self-serve, bulk, no support. ✓ (Xiameter) 3. Did Xiameter cannibalize Dow Corning sales? <10%; mostly new customers. ✓ (ICMR) 4. How fast did it pay back? 3 months on infra. Double-digit growth yearly post-2002. ✓ (Reliable Plant) 5. Xiameter discount amount? 10-15% vs main brand; analysts eyed 20%. ✓ (Biznology) 6. Who led Xiameter? CFO Don Sheets; Stephanie Burns scaled as CEO (2003+). ✓ (Chief Executive) 7. What happened to Xiameter? Integrated into Dow Silicones 2018; model endures. 8. B2B e-commerce viability today? Xiameter pioneered; now 30%+ industry norm. 9. Why do most dual-brand strategies fail? Three killers: fuzzy segmentation (GM Saturn), internal sabotage (sales teams favor margins), and price anchor collapse (cheap resets all expectations). 10. What is Dow Corning known for today? After 2016 Dow buyout and 2018 restructuring, operates as Dow Silicones within Dow Inc. Still world's largest silicone producer. 11. Is Xiameter still operating? The brand exists at xiameter.com but is now integrated into Dow's e-commerce platform rather than a standalone business unit. 12. How does self-cannibalization differ from price cutting? Price cuts erode your entire brand. A separate brand isolates the discount to a distinct customer segment, protecting premium margins.

Related Reads - DuPont CEO Escape Oil (capital allocation cluster) - Phrozen Founders (founder ops) - Howard Schultz Starbucks Turnaround (recovery pivot)

Sources 1. Wikipedia: Dow Corning 2. LA Times 1995 Bankruptcy 3. Computerworld: Xiameter Launch 4. Rubber News: $6B Revenue 5. Biznology: 40% Sales 6. Chief Executive: Don Sheets 7. ICMR Case: Cannibalization 8. McKinsey Interview 9. Reliable Plant: Growth 10. Justia Bankruptcy 11. Gerald Ford Foundation: Sheets Bio